Skip to Main Content

Turf Moor Diaries: A Sideways Move That Leaves Clarets Fans Asking Why

05/1/2010 10:05 AM GMT By Alastair Campbell

    • Alastair Campbell
As we trooped out of the stadium at Milton Keynes on Saturday, I bumped into Dave Burnley, one of our greatest fans.

He has missed one game since the mid-1970s, changed his name by deed poll, named his daughter Clarette in honour of the club's colours, and written a terrific book about his life as an extreme football fan, called Got To Be There.

He was wearing his trademark ripped sheepskin coat and looking really happy, not merely because of the rare away win but because of his interpretation of Owen Coyle's salute to the fans at the end of the match.

"He's definitely staying, definitely," he said. "Big wave, thumbs up, that is not a man who is walking away from us."

Dave is a walking encyclopaedia on matters Claret, but that was one he got badly wrong. Unlike my son Calum, who had already decided that if Coyle had wanted to quell the rumours, he could have done so, and the fact that he hadn't meant he was already half-way out the door.

Right now, in common with many other Burnley supporters, Dave Burnley will be angry and disappointed, both at Coyle's departure, and the manner of it. Holding out the prospect of staying, after last night's "sleep on it" meeting with chairman Barry Kilby, has simply added to the sense of disappointment, as only dashed hope can. As for Calum, he is telling his Arsenal mates how much he hopes they stuff Bolton tomorrow.

I cannot say I am surprised he has gone. As I said here on Saturday, the bookies rarely get the big managerial calls wrong, not 5-2 odds on, take no more bets wrong at any rate. The minute Coyle became the runaway favourite, you sensed it was only a matter of time. There was also the odd business of him not facing the media after the match on Saturday.

Coyle likes talking to the telly, and he is very good at it. Even though he was flying to Scotland to see his family - and I understand the flight was booked two days earlier so there is no reason to disbelieve that - it would have been easy enough to fit in a quick interview, or get the club spokesman to brief what he would have said.

But by then it was clear that he was on his way to Bolton via Glasgow. Yesterday's Daily Mirror was the final clue. A story written by Alan Nixon, Coyle's closest media friend from way back, stated definitively that he was leaving.

So though I am not surprised that he's going, I am surprised that he wants to.

Bolton fans make a lot of the fact that Coyle played for the club, which will have added a certain emotional pull. But if you are talking about emotion, how much bigger would the pull have been when the call came from Celtic, the club he supported as a child in his native Glasgow?

His argument then, as when he was linked with the Scotland job after George Burley was sacked, was that he was flattered but too committed to what he was trying to build at Burnley.

It is hard to see what Bolton gives him that makes that commitment so easily breached. England cricketer Jimmy Anderson summed it up rather well in an incredulous sounding tweet from South Africa. "Leaving Burnley for Bolton?" It is not just Burnley people like Jimmy who will be asking that.

Yes, it is a bigger club. But not that much bigger, which is why a lot of football people are seeing it as a sideways move.

He was on around a million pounds a year at Burnley, so even if he has managed to get a rise on that, I'd be surprised if it is that much more. Nothing to match the percentage rise he got in moving from St Johnstone to Burnley, or in going from Championship Burnley to Premier League Burnley. It is true that Coyle did a lot for Burnley. But Burnley did a lot for Coyle. And I hope they hang tough on the compensation package, someone seemingly having jumped the gun in claiming it had been agreed before last night's meeting.

Doubtless he will have been promised some money to buy new players. But Bolton's finances are not that great. Far from it. And one of the reasons his reputation is so strong is that he has shown it is possible to manage a low-budget team, play good football, get to the top flight and make a good fist at survival.

If he had stayed at Burnley, and we had gone down despite all his efforts, his reputation would still have been strong and he would still have been in the running for bigger jobs.

But if he fails to keep Bolton up, it will be a reputational blow. And if he cements them as a mid-table Premier League club, he is in reputational limbo.

For taking Burnley to the Premier League for the first time, Coyle has already secured his place in the club's history. The reason people feel so disappointed today is precisely because he seemed like a cut above the average football manager. He seemed to get just how much this club meant to the town. People liked his engaging and outgoing personality. They liked the attractive football he made his players play. They loved the Cup runs last year. Above all, they loved promotion and the Premier League adventure.

The adventure is still on, and the memories are still there. But it is very sad that someone who was so key to it has disappeared down the road.

Meanwhile, Bolton v Burnley at the Reebok two weeks from today could be one of the hottest games of a season already packed with them.

Read More:   , ,

Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Writers

Photos

FanHouse UK brings you all the latest English Premier League news and live match coverage. It offers intelligent, informed insight and original authoritative reporting.

Back To The Top